TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT VIRES

November 20th, 2026 by James Goudie KC

In SWINDON BC v THAMES WATER UTILITIES ( TW ) ( 2026 ) EWCA Civ 1464 TW challenged the vires of the PERMIT SCHEME ( PS ) adopted by the Council, a local highway authority and “ permit authority “ ( PA ). The PS (1) had been introduced under the Traffic Management Act 2004 ( the TMA ), and (2) is regulated by the TMA ( Permit Scheme ) ( England ) Regulations 2007, pursuant to the TMA. The PS provides for the fixing of fees for permits allowing undertakers, such as TW, to undertake ROADWORKS in the Council’s area. The PS sets the level of fees, and does so by taking account DEFICITS which had accrued from previous years’ TW argued that fees could be set only on the basis of achieving a COST NEUTRAL position on an ANNUAL BASIS. The challenge failed on appeal. The TMA provides that in making the Regulations the Secretary of State should seek to ensure that FEES DO NOT EXCEED PRESCRIBED COSTS, in accordance with the general principle that a power to make delegated legislation cannot be used to impose taxation, fees or other charges without CLEAR AUTHORITY. The Court of Appeal considered that the words of the Regulations, having regard to their overall structure and purpose, do NOT prevent a PA setting FEES AT A LEVEL TO OFFSET PAST DEFICITS, or, conversely, to take into account PAST SURPLUSES. The Court of Appeal regards TW’s reliance on Section 111 of the Local Government Act 1972 as “ inapposite “, reminding us ( para 67 ) that the “ case law is very clear “ that Section 111 cannot be used as “ an escape route “ from a statutory scheme : CREDIT SUISSE v ALLERDALE DC ( 1997 ) QB 3o7 ( Court of Appeal ). The Court of Appeal also found ( paras 73/74 ) that the Statutory Guidance “ points strongly” against TW’s construction.

Comments are closed.